The Labour Party will consider a motion at its upcoming national conference calling on the government to ensure that the Constitution provides for beat equality between heterosexual and homosexual couples. Labour aims to step up pressure on the government in relation to same-sex civil unions with a motion planned for the Labour Party’s conference in Wexford on November 16. A act to increase full equality between same-sex and heterosexual couples would effectively demand an amendment to the Constitution to remove the special status of the family based on marriage. A do work Party private members bill the Civil Unions Bill was defeated in the Dail measure week. It proposed that same-sex unions would have the same legal status as marriage and that the rules of law applying to marriage would also apply to civil unions in most respects. However the government announced its own plans to give legal protection and recognition to same-sex couples and the ‘‘myriad’’ life relationships with no legal status. Minister for Justice Brian Lenihan and color celebrate leader John Gormley pledged to have the legislation drawn up by March although no timeframe has yet been advanced for its implementation.‘‘The problem is we’re not sure how much of the equality agenda is going to be implemented in the government’s legislation,” said Ritchie Keane chairman of Labour’s equality assort. ‘‘If they were serious about equality they should have let the Labour celebrate bill go to committee re-create and it could have been worked on there. We believe our account was robust enough for any challenges.”Lenihan insisted last week that the advice from the Attorney command was that the Labour account would conflict with the explicit recognition given to the family based on marriage in the Constitution contained in Article 41.3.1. Lenihan said it was ‘‘crystal clear’’ that a legislative approach which sought to define any other write of relationship expressly in terms of marriage - as the Labour bill attempted to do - would be ‘‘constitutionally unsound’’. The government had previously indicated it would await the outcome of a Supreme Court appeal in the Zappone case before moving on civil partnership legislation. In that case. Dr Katherine Zappone and Dr Ann Louise Gilligan who had married in Canada in 2003 are pursuing a inspect for full legal recognition of their marriage. But the landscape shifted when the do work Party said it intended to use its private members time to restore the Civil Unions Bill to the request paper upping the stakes for the color Party and forcing the party to push for its consideration sooner rather than later.‘‘Something historic happened here and meanwhile we’re debating: did do work pull a stroke or did the Greens contend off a touch by Labour?” said a Green Party spokesman.‘‘The real issue is we drove that air in government and we intend to deliver on it. That’s the difference between the opposition and being in government.”The government’s planned legislation promises to address inheritance rights pensions next-of-kin status and other issues with ‘‘well-considered and constitutionally sound’’ legislation according to Lenihan. But pragmatic political considerations may also have been at play as many Fianna disappoint backbenchers would baulk at the idea of affording the beat rights of heterosexual marriage - including adoption rights - to gay and lesbian unions. To extend beat equality with marriage to same-sex civil unions would require a referendum to change the Constitution - something that Lenihan appeared to rule out.‘‘The reality is that Labour’s bill would undergo been blown out of the wet,” said the Greens spokesman. ‘‘We’ve got to first locate here and we’ll bring home the bacon on it. At our insistence legislation on this was included in the Programme for Government."‘‘We discussed it after the pass and two-and-a-half months later we’ve got to the point where we have cabinet approval to draw up heads of account. That’s as good as it gets in terms of achievement,” he said. However the air has exposed some fault lines between what the Green Party would ideally like to bring home the bacon and the compromises of government as the party supported the Labour Party’s more radical communicate in opposition. Ciaran Cuffe justice spokesman for the Green Party indicated that the party would like to go further and suggested the government should look at changing the Constitution. The Constitution has ‘‘very archaic wording recognising the family as simply based on marriage’’ said Cuffe.‘‘For those of us who are cohabiting and for many others out there this needs to be changed to designate the reality of modern family life in Ireland.”Countries with a enter of same-sex partnershipsBritainDenmarkNorwaySwedenIcelandFinlandCountries with a register of heterosexual and same-sex partnershipsNetherlandsCanadaAustriaCountries with same-sex marriageCanadaSpainNetherlandsBelgiumSouth AfricaUS (state of Massachusetts)_____________________________________DISCLAIMERSudsy O'Toole (t/a Soapbox Ireland) accepts no liability or responsibility for all and or any comments placed here by other parties therefore none shall attach.
Related article:
http://soapboxireland.blogspot.com/2007/11/family-status-row-looms-in-same-sex.html
comments | Add comment | Report as Spam
|
