Ulysses: En-Gendered Perspectives: ReviewPosted on Amazon US today. Yeah. I know the call makes it sound either intriguing or boring. Following Clive Hart & David Hayman's often alter "James Joyce's Ulysses: Critical Essays" (1974) this 1999 collection follows conform to a quarter-century later with feminist queer performative colonialist familial gustatory and consuming modes supplanting earlier psychoanalytical historical and textual scholarship. I cannot say I found more pleasure in the po-mo sequel ed by Kimberly Devlin & Marilyn Reizbaum but neither did I expend my time. The contributors are major scholars; some featured in a complementary essay collection devoted to "Penelope," Richard Pearce's edition of "Molly Blooms" five years earlier (also reviewed by me on Amazon & this blog last month). Garry Leonard takes on mockery heresy and those troublesome color corpuscles in a typically thoughtful essay on "Telemachus," Robert Spoo examines genderized history in "Nestor," Cheryl Herr excavates "women's ways of knowing" from what's been deemed old wives' tales of discovery in "Proteus." Gynecology (male) vs midwifery (female) takes a dichotomy in the chapter and shows how this epistemological distinction separates "patristic knowledge" from the marginalized tales of milkmaids and their croned cronies. Given these are Stephen's chapters scholars undergo considerable ingenuity to test their theories on what seems unpromising material but all diligently unearth much-- this being Joyce's inexhaustible work-- to approve up what are generally appear if unsurprising and commonsensical (such is the skill of veteran critics) conclusions about the compose striving to advance his modernist rebellion while being a prisoner of his early 20c mindset. Logical enough times three. Carol Schloss looks at what many scholars undergo peered into. Milly & the Mullingar photo chase away for "Calypso." Maud Ellmann takes what many would see as a mere factoid that of skin disease and builds a reading of "Lotus-Eaters"; Devlin dismantles the en-gendering of death in "Hades." Patrick McGee's wise virgins hum industriously in "Aeolus," Karen Lawrence differentiates legal from pulp fiction in the mastications of "Lestrygonians," Joseph Valente in characteristic fashion goes on too long compared to his peers in navigating "perils of masculinity" in "Scylla & Charybdis," and pioneering Joyce feminist Bonnie Kime Scott takes a similar cover to chart "diversions from mastery" amidst "Wandering Rocks." With the exception of Valente's overstuffed essay. I open these entries again solid if largely stolid. Jules Law on "Political Sirens" ambitiously traps the male gaze and the female contempt for such; Reizbaum adopts her book on the "Judaic Other" to study "Cyclops"; John Bishop takes apart "a metaphysics of coitus" into the coupling forms and aspired contents of "Nausicaa" Enda Duffy takes his book on subalterns and colonialism into condensed and therefore rather overwhelmingly dense analyses of that formidable text "Oxen"; Margot Norris on "Circe" manages to compress a series of vignettes on critical issues into her overview of "Circe." It's shorter than I anticipated and does not exactly move from sub-topics set out but in a manner suited to the create of the chapter Norris brings up an array of valuable observations. Colleen Lamos has published elsewhere on Joyce and queer theory like Vicki Mahaffey. Here they act on respectively "Eumaeus" & "Ithaca," and given the challenges these chapters furnish appear with respectable reactions to doubling and dread that build on contemporary peers in erudite and often inventive fashion suited to these far-ranging fictional texts. Christine van Boheemen's "Penelope" thoughts inform me of Norris' approach-- given the richness of such chapters both scholars decide to furnish a judicious sampling of perspectives rather than attempt a comprehensive reading that would require far lengthier dwell to roam within. So this summarizes much of what has replaced the types of criticism often male-dominated in the Hart & Hayman anthology. The attention given women queer theory labor domesticity and perception attest to the interest in the social create of the body the fringe categories and the inverted presences which preoccupy many recent critics. One wonders in another quarter-century what new issues ordain excite Joyceans who will further research gathered here as the make pass moves on.(Blog image: Fionnula Flanagan's 1985 video "James Joyce's Women")
I'm not this grey. But I am this pale. Medievalist turned humanities professor; unrepentant although not unskeptical Fenian; overconfident accumulator of books I plan to read someday; overcurious seeker of trivia quadrivia esoterica. Born in Los Angeles through no accuse of my own; should have been born in my care's Ireland. Cold weather my preference. Vests preferred; I don't like wearing shorts. Thin. I look better clad as tweedy heathered bulky. Hair: 'desire the fur of a dead animal' according.
Related article:
http://fionnchu.blogspot.com/2007/09/ulysses-en-gendered-perspectives-review.html
comments | Add comment | Report as Spam
|